You Either Love It or Hate It: 16 Polarizing American Dishes

Some foods just come with drama, and I’m not talking about burnt toast. I mean those polarizing American dishes you either love or hate—like, full-on debate-at-the-dinner-table level drama. One bite could send you straight to comfort food heaven or make you wonder how it ever became a classic. Either way, these recipes have a reputation, and they’re not going down quietly.

Love It or Loathe It: Ambrosia Salad With Marshmallows

A glass bowl filled with creamy fruit salad, inspired by vintage recipes, is topped with a red maraschino cherry; the salad contains marshmallows, fruit pieces, and whipped cream. Silver spoons rest beside the bowl on a gray surface. — Ambrosia Fruit Salad With Marshmallows. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

This creamy, coconut-laced fruit salad sparks nostalgia in some—and confusion in others. Is it dessert or a side? You decide.
Get the Recipe: Ambrosia Fruit Salad With Marshmallows

Meatloaf With Oatmeal: A Comfort Classic or Dinnertime Debate?

A close-up of two slices of savory meatloaf topped with a rich red sauce on a dark blue plate. A fork and knife are placed next to the meatloaf on the plate. The background surface is light blue, and a pumpkin-shaped dish is partially visible in the top right corner. — A Perfectly Moist Meatloaf Made With Oatmeal. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Warm Up Your Winter: Southern Classics!

FREE EMAIL BONUS: Southern staples made simply & cozy

This old-school meatloaf, made with oatmeal and a sweet glaze, is pure comfort for some—and a nonstarter for others.
Get the Recipe: A Perfectly Moist Meatloaf Made With Oatmeal

Cream Cheese Deviled Eggs: Elegant or Excessive?

Deviled eggs with mustard and herbs. — The Best Cream Cheese Deviled Eggs Recipe. Photo credit: Intentional Hospitality.

Rich, creamy, and tangy—these deviled eggs with cream cheese are beloved at gatherings but not everyone’s cup of yolk.
Get the Recipe: The Best Cream Cheese Deviled Eggs Recipe

Cheesy Spaghetti Casserole: Comfort or Culinary Crime?

Cheese being pulled from a pot of spaghetti with two spoons. — Cheesy Spaghetti Casserole With Ground Beef. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

This beefy, cheesy casserole hits the spot for some—but that can of mushroom soup may be a dealbreaker for others.
Get the Recipe: Cheesy Spaghetti Casserole With Ground Beef

Southern Chicken and Dumplings: Soul Food or Too Soupy?

Close-up of a bowl of chicken and dumplings. A spoon rests in the bowl, lifting one of the dumplings. The golden broth, shredded chicken, and sprinkled herbs on top are visible, giving a savory and comforting appearance to the dish. — Southern Chicken And Dumplings With Steamed Biscuits. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Thick broth, tender chicken, and fluffy steamed biscuits—pure bliss for some, but others say, “Too mushy!”
Get the Recipe: Southern Chicken And Dumplings With Steamed Biscuits

Tuna Noodle Casserole: Nostalgic Favorite or Fishy Flop?

A large white pot filled with creamy noodle casserole, perfect for weeknight dinners, topped with crumbled potato chips, sliced green onions, and mixed vegetables, with a serving spoon on the side. — Tuna Noodle Casserole Recipe (No Soup). Photo credit: Lauren’s Latest.

Love the crunch of chips and creamy tuna? Or do you dread this retro casserole showing up at dinner?
Get the Recipe: Tuna Noodle Casserole Recipe (No Soup)

Sticky Sweet Baked Beans With Beef: Classic or Clashing?

A skillet of cooked baked beans. — Sticky Sweet Baked Beans With Beef. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

These smoky baked beans with beef are a backyard staple—but not everyone’s a fan of beans with meat.
Get the Recipe: Sticky Sweet Baked Beans With Beef

Broccoli Rice Casserole: Love It or Skip It?

A broccoli rice casserole in a skillet. — Creamy Broccoli Rice Casserole Without Canned Soup. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Creamy, cheesy, and full of broccoli—this casserole is a cozy classic or a green-speckled “no thanks,” depending on who you ask.
Get the Recipe: Creamy Broccoli Rice Casserole Without Canned Soup

Jalapeno Popper Deviled Eggs: Bold or Just Too Much?

A close-up of deviled eggs topped with creamy yolk mixture, crispy bacon bits, and a slice of fresh jalapeño, set against a dark background. — Jalapeno Popper Deviled Eggs. Photo credit: Spicy Southern Kitchen.

Spicy, creamy, and bacon-loaded—these deviled eggs fire up fans and critics alike. Are they genius or just overkill?
Get the Recipe: Jalapeno Popper Deviled Eggs

Green Bean Casserole: Holiday Hero or Canned Catastrophe?

A serving spoon in a green bean casserole made from scratch, — Creamy Green Bean Casserole Without Canned Soup. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Fresh green beans and creamy homemade sauce—this version skips the can, but the casserole still divides the table.
Get the Recipe: Creamy Green Bean Casserole Without Canned Soup

Strawberry Pretzel Salad: Dessert or Mystery?

A square of strawberry pretzel salad — Strawberry Pretzel Salad Recipe. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Crunchy, creamy, and jiggly—this layered retro dessert sparks joy for some and side-eyes from others.
Get the Recipe: Strawberry Pretzel Salad Recipe

Boston Baked Beans: Crock Pot Comfort or Sugar Bomb?

Bacon and beans in a skillet. — Boston Baked Bean Recipe In The Crock Pot. Photo credit: Intentional Hospitality.

Molasses, bacon, and slow-cooked flavor—these beans are beloved in New England, but not everyone appreciates the sweetness.
Get the Recipe: Boston Baked Bean Recipe In The Crock Pot

Classic Deviled Eggs: Iconic or Overdone?

A deviled egg being removed from a platter. — Classic Deviled Eggs- Just 4 Ingredients. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Mayo, mustard, and paprika—this classic appetizer stirs up strong feelings at every picnic and potluck.
Get the Recipe: Classic Deviled Eggs- Just 4 Ingredients

Southern Fried Okra: Amazing or Appalling?

Fried Okra stacked on a plate. — Southern Fried Okra Recipe. Photo credit: Spicy Southern Kitchen.

Golden and crunchy, these okra bites are Southern gold—or a slimy “no thanks” if you’re not into the texture.
Get the Recipe: Southern Fried Okra Recipe

Tuna & Noodle Casserole: Timeless or Tired?

A baked tuna casserole in a sillet. — Tuna & Noodle Casserole Without Canned Soup. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

This creamy tuna classic, topped with potato chips, is a blast from the past that some love—and others dodge.
Get the Recipe: Tuna & Noodle Casserole Without Canned Soup

Easy Deviled Eggs: Easter Essential or Party Pass?

Deviled eggs with green onions. — Easy Deviled Eggs Recipe. Photo credit: Lauren’s Latest.

These classic deviled eggs show up at every holiday—but their strong flavor and texture aren’t for everyone.
Get the Recipe: Easy Deviled Eggs Recipe

Explore Recipes

MSN Slideshows