If You Only Bake One Pie This Fall, Make It One of These 25

Crisp fall days practically beg for something warm and sweet from the oven, and pie always feels like the coziest choice. If you’re planning to bake one pie this fall, the hardest part might be deciding which flavor deserves the spotlight. From classic apple to decadent pecan and everything in between, there are plenty of tempting options. Grab your favorite spices and get ready to enjoy the ultimate slice of autumn comfort.

Apple Custard Pie Worth Baking This Fall

Apple custard pie blends tender apples with creamy custard in a flaky crust. If you only bake one pie this fall, this cozy, lightly spiced classic deserves the spot.
Get the Recipe: Apple Custard Pie Worth Baking This Fall

Key Lime Mousse Pie That Deserves a Spot This Fall

A sliced key lime pie next to a pie server. — Key Lime Mousse Pie That Deserves a Spot This Fall. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

My All-American Summer Menu 🇺🇸

FREE EMAIL BONUS: Delicious summer recipes just in time for the season

Key lime pie may be no-bake, but its tangy creaminess feels refreshing and bright. Bake one pie this fall that stands out, and let this citrus favorite surprise you.
Get the Recipe: Key Lime Mousse Pie That Deserves a Spot This Fall

Eggnog Custard Pie to Celebrate the Season

A single slice of eggnog pie. — Eggnog Custard Pie to Celebrate the Season. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Eggnog pie turns holiday flavors into a creamy, spiced custard that feels festive and fun. If you only bake one pie this fall, this cheerful favorite brings the season right to the table.
Get the Recipe: Eggnog Custard Pie to Celebrate the Season

Kentucky Derby Pie That Belongs on Your Fall Table

A derby pie with two slices. — Kentucky Derby Pie That Belongs on Your Fall Table. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Derby pie is a Kentucky classic with chocolate, nuts, and a buttery filling. When you bake just one pie this fall, make it this rich and indulgent winner.
Get the Recipe: Kentucky Derby Pie That Belongs on Your Fall Table

Pecan Pie Without Corn Syrup to Bake This Fall

Close-up of sliced pecan pie with a golden brown crust, topped with whole and chopped pecans, displayed on a white plate—perfect inspiration for your Christmas pie recipes. — Pecan Pie Without Corn Syrup to Bake This Fall. Photo credit: Intentional Hospitality.

Pecan pie without corn syrup proves you don’t need shortcuts for big flavor. If you bake only one pie this fall, let it be this simpler, timeless Southern favorite.
Get the Recipe: Pecan Pie Without Corn Syrup to Bake This Fall

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie You’ll Want This Season

A slice of peanut butter pie with a chocolate cookie crust, perfect for fans of chocolate desserts, is topped with chopped peanut butter cups, peanuts, and drizzled with chocolate syrup on a white plate. — Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie You’ll Want This Season. Photo credit: Intentional Hospitality.

Chocolate peanut butter pie layers nutty creaminess over an Oreo crust for pure comfort. Bake one pie this fall and make it this no-bake showstopper.
Get the Recipe: Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie You’ll Want This Season

Millionaire Pie That Fits Right Into Fall

A slice of creamy coconut pie topped with whipped cream, two pecan halves, and two red cherries, served on a white plate—a festive no bake Christmas treat. A bowl of red cherries is visible in the background. — Millionaire Pie That Fits Right Into Fall. Photo credit: Intentional Hospitality.

Millionaire pie is creamy, tropical, and impossibly easy to make ahead. If you only bake one pie this fall, let this indulgent favorite carry the celebration.
Get the Recipe: Millionaire Pie That Fits Right Into Fall

Mini Apple Pies That Make Fall Baking Easy

A close-up of a sweet pastry filled with glossy apple pie filling and drizzled with white icing. Perfect for fans of quick dessert recipes, the golden-brown pastry is soft and fluffy, with a bite revealing its delicious inside. — Mini Apple Pies That Make Fall Baking Easy. Photo credit: Semi Homemade Kitchen.

A glossy apple pie pastry drizzled with icing delivers warmth in every bite. If you bake one pie this fall, this soft, golden classic deserves a place on your table.
Get the Recipe: Mini Apple Pies That Make Fall Baking Easy

Butterscotch Pie You’ll Be Glad You Baked

A close-up of a slice of creamy peanut butter pie with a graham cracker crust, topped with whipped cream and peanut butter chips, being lifted from a pie dish—perfect as one of your no bake Christmas treats. — Butterscotch Pie You’ll Be Glad You Baked. Photo credit: Semi Homemade Kitchen.

Butterscotch pie is creamy, rich, and made with just a handful of ingredients. Bake one pie this fall, and you’ll see why this no-bake dessert is a go-to.
Get the Recipe: Butterscotch Pie You’ll Be Glad You Baked

Chocolate Strawberry Jello Pie That Works for Fall

A pink pie with a chocolate crust, reminiscent of old fashioned pies, is topped with chocolate-covered strawberries and two white meringue cookies, sitting next to a bowl of chocolate chips on a white surface. — Chocolate Strawberry Jello Pie That Works for Fall. Photo credit: Intentional Hospitality.

Chocolate strawberry jello pie turns the classic dipped treat into a creamy slice. If you bake just one pie this fall, this family favorite is worth the spotlight.
Get the Recipe: Chocolate Strawberry Jello Pie That Works for Fall

Orange Jello Pie That Brings Brightness to Fall

Three mini orange cream pies with graham cracker crusts, topped with a dollop of whipped cream and a slice of orange, sit on a white surface next to a striped towel—perfect for fans of easy dessert recipes. — Orange Jello Pie That Brings Brightness to Fall. Photo credit: Intentional Hospitality.

Orange jello pie brings a creamy, citrus kick to the dessert table. Bake one pie this fall and let this bright, cool favorite round out the meal.
Get the Recipe: Orange Jello Pie That Brings Brightness to Fall

Black Forest Cherry Jello Pie for a Sweet Fall Treat

A pink mousse no bake pie in a chocolate crust, topped with cherries, whipped cream swirls, and chocolate shavings. Pieces of chocolate and cherries are in bowls nearby, with a pink-striped cloth at the side. — Black Forest Cherry Jello Pie for a Sweet Fall Treat. Photo credit: Intentional Hospitality.

Black Forest cherry jello pie gives you all the flavors of the cake in an easier form. If you only bake one pie this fall, this fruity twist is the one.
Get the Recipe: Black Forest Cherry Jello Pie for a Sweet Fall Treat

Buttermilk Pie That Defines Southern Fall Baking

A buttermilk pie that has been cut into slices. — Buttermilk Pie That Defines Southern Fall Baking. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Buttermilk pie is a Southern staple with a tangy custard filling that feels timeless. Bake one pie this fall, and let this nostalgic favorite take center stage.
Get the Recipe: Buttermilk Pie That Defines Southern Fall Baking

Coconut Cream Pie to Enjoy This Fall

A coconut custard pie with a slice removed. — Coconut Cream Pie to Enjoy This Fall. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Coconut cream pie is rich with custard and finished with whipped cream. If you bake only one pie this fall, make it this tropical classic.
Get the Recipe: Coconut Cream Pie to Enjoy This Fall

Pumpkin Pie That Always Wins the Season

A pumpkin pie with a slice removed. — Pumpkin Pie That Always Wins the Season. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Pumpkin pie delivers the smooth, spiced filling that defines fall holidays. Bake one pie this season, and this must-have classic will always win.
Get the Recipe: Pumpkin Pie That Always Wins the Season

Chocolate Chess Pie You’ll Want on the Fall Menu

A chocolate chess pie topped with whip cream swirls. — Chocolate Chess Pie You’ll Want on the Fall Menu. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Chocolate chess pie is fudgy, silky, and full of cocoa flavor. If you only bake one pie this fall, make it this easy Southern classic.
Get the Recipe: Chocolate Chess Pie You’ll Want on the Fall Menu

S’mores Pie That Brings Campfire Flavor Into Fall

S’mores pie layers marshmallow, chocolate, and graham cracker for gooey fun. Bake one pie this fall and let it bring back childhood memories.
Get the Recipe: S’mores Pie That Brings Campfire Flavor Into Fall

Turtle Pie That Makes Fall Extra Indulgent

Turtle pie combines chocolate, caramel, and pecans in a creamy, decadent filling. If you bake only one pie this fall, let it be this indulgent favorite.
Get the Recipe: Turtle Pie That Makes Fall Extra Indulgent

Sweet Potato Pie That Feels Right for the Season

Sweet potato pie with condensed milk is smooth, spiced, and deeply comforting. Bake one pie this fall, and this Southern classic will taste like home.
Get the Recipe: Sweet Potato Pie That Feels Right for the Season

Chocolate Pecan Pie That’s Perfect for Fall Gatherings

Chocolate pecan pie adds a fudgy layer to the nutty holiday favorite. If you only bake one pie this fall, this decadent twist is the one to choose.
Get the Recipe: Chocolate Pecan Pie That’s Perfect for Fall Gatherings

Blackberry Pie That Tastes Like Fall Comfort

A top-down view of a partially eaten blackberry pie with a lattice crust on a wire cooling rack. The pie has a crispy golden-brown crust with juicy, dark purple filling. A bowl of whipped cream is placed nearby. Crumbs and a piece of pie are visible on the table. — Blackberry Pie That Tastes Like Fall Comfort. Photo credit: Easy Southern Desserts.

Blackberry pie bursts with juicy fruit inside a golden, flaky crust. Bake one pie this fall, and this classic deserves to be paired with ice cream.
Get the Recipe: Blackberry Pie That Tastes Like Fall Comfort

Cream Cheese Pie You’ll Want on the Fall Dessert Table

Cream cheese pie is smooth, tangy, and endlessly versatile. If you only bake one pie this fall, make it this simple but indulgent option.
Get the Recipe: Cream Cheese Pie You’ll Want on the Fall Dessert Table

Chocolate Brownie Pie That Makes Fall Sweeter

Chocolate brownie pie is gooey and fudgy with the bonus of a flaky crust. Bake one pie this fall, and you’ll be glad it was this rich twist.
Get the Recipe: Chocolate Brownie Pie That Makes Fall Sweeter

Vanilla Custard Pie That Fits Every Fall Occasion

Vanilla pie highlights the elegance of pure vanilla in a silky custard filling. If you only bake one pie this fall, this timeless classic belongs on the table.
Get the Recipe: Vanilla Custard Pie That Fits Every Fall Occasion

Southern Possum Pie That Belongs in Fall Baking

Possum pie layers chocolate, cream cheese, and whipped topping over a pecan crust. Bake one pie this fall, and this playful Southern treat will steal the show.
Get the Recipe: Southern Possum Pie That Belongs in Fall Baking

I Followed Grandma’s 1950s Recipe Cards—Here Are the 17 That Still Win Hearts

A collage of three desserts evokes when church potlucks ruled the weekend: top left, a sliced fluffy angel food cake; bottom left, banana pudding with whipped cream; right, a baked meringue pie in a white pie dish. — I Followed Grandma’s 1950s Recipe Cards—Here Are the 17 That Still Win Hearts. Photo credit: Butter and Baggage.

Flipping through grandma’s recipe cards from the 1950s felt like uncovering a little piece of history. A few dishes were all about nostalgia, while others proved they’re just as delicious now as they were back then. It’s amazing how those faded notes still carry so much comfort—and plenty of flavor—to the table.
Grab it here: I Followed Grandma’s 1950s Recipe Cards—Here Are the 17 That Still Win Hearts

Explore Recipes

MSN Slideshows