Scalloped Sweet Potatoes with Two Types of Potatoes

Scalloped sweet potatoes are a delicious and elegant side dish that are perfect for any occasion. Thinly sliced sweet potatoes and Yukon Gold potatoes are layered in a buttery, creamy sauce and baked until tender and golden. Both sweet and savory, scalloped sweet potatoes are sure to impress your dinner guests and become a family favorite.

For those occasions, when you want an impressive looking side dish that will also taste amazing, choose a sweet potato casserole with layers and layers of two types of potatoes.

This easy to make scalloped sweet potato recipe is a tender and flavorful side dish that everyone is going to love. With beautiful layered potatoes that compliment nearly any meal, this is guaranteed to be a show stopper. If layers are your thing, try layering apples and sweet potatoes.

Thinly sliced sweet potatoes and Yukon Gold potatoes are baked in a creamy sauce then topped with cheese. When the sweet potatoes absorb the cream, it leaves them with the perfect balance of savory flavors and hint of natural sweetness.

This casserole is easy enough to serve for a family dinner and gorgeous enough for the holiday table. The layers of sweet potatoes and regular potatoes come together and form a delicious, yet impressive casserole.

Not to mention, this sweet potato gratin is the perfect side dish to just about any main course. I love serving it with steak marsala, pork tenderloin or stuffed chicken breast. Of course, It will also go great with ham or turkey for your next holiday dinner!

While I love the flavors of a mashed sweet potato casserole, the potatoes in this casserole will soften but still maintain their shape so that you can serve it as a beautiful block of potatoes.

An added benefit if you are serving this with other sides, is that it needs to rest for at least 15 minutes before cutting which gives you enough time to cook some dinner rolls.

Why everyone reaches for seconds!

• The cream absorbs into the potatoes as they cook
• The fresh thyme and parsley add subtle flavor
• It’s a restaurant quality sweet potato casserole that’s easy to prepare
• Great recipe for special occasions
• It will feed a crowd

Ingredients you’ll need

• Potatoes – A combination of sweet potatoes and Yukon gold potatoes not only tastes good, but it creates beautiful layers in the casserole.
• Fresh herbs – Using fresh parsley and fresh thyme is an easy way to elevate these scalloped potatoes
• Cream – Pairing heavy cream with half-and-half ensures you get all the creamy flavor without the casserole becoming too dense.
• Cheese – I prefer gruyère cheese but feel free to experiment with parmesan cheese, Monterey jack, sharp cheddar cheese, or other types of cheeses.

Pro tip: If you don’t have half-and-half, for each cup of half-and-half, substitute ¾ cups whole milk and ¼ heavy cream.

Can I prep sweet potatoes ahead of time?

Cutting the potatoes in advance is a great way to save some time. However, raw potatoes will turn brown so it’s best to store cut potatoes in cold water in the fridge.

Simple steps

Step 1: Get everything ready

Preheat the oven, spray a large casserole dish, and thinly slice the potatoes with a mandolin or food processor. You an also use a knife, just try to get them as thin as possible.

Step 2: Layer

Arrange some of the Yukon potatoes into the bottom of the baking dish. Top with herbs and butter.

Step 3: Repeat

Alternating between Yukon and sweet potatoes, finish layering the casserole.

Step 4: Final touches

Pour the cream mixture over the layers of potatoes, top with cheese, and bake, covered for 40 minutes. then uncover and top with cheese and bake until it is golden brown.

Pro tip: Let these gruyere scalloped potatoes sit at least 15 minutes before cutting with a sharp knife. This way, the layers can set and you won’t be left with a mess.

Can you make homemade scalloped potatoes in advance?

Yes, you can prep this easy casserole recipe ahead of time. Simply cover with plastic wrap and let it come to room temperature before you put it in the oven. You can store the prepped casserole in the fridge for up to 12 hours before baking.

Potato pointers

• Sprinkle some brown sugar or drizzle some maple syrup on top of the potatoes before baking for a little sweetness.
• You can heat these scalloped potatoes up as leftovers the next day.
• If you’re having trouble slicing the potatoes, try a mandolin slicer.

Common sweet potato questions

What is the difference between scalloped and au gratin potatoes?

Both types of potatoes are baked in cream, but au gratin potatoes typically have cheese layered throughout the potatoes and not just sprinkled on top.

How long does it take scalloped potatoes to cook?

The cooking time for scalloped potatoes will vary depending on how thick the potato slices are. The thinner the slices the less time it will take. You will need to bake this for at least an hour.

Can I freeze a potato casserole?

You can freeze this sweet potato casserole. Just let it come to room temperature and then reheat in the oven.

More sweet potato casseroles you’ll love

If you loved this recipe, give it a star ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ rating! Also, snap a picture of your finished dish and share it with me on Instagram using the hashtag #butterandbaggage and tagging me @butterandbaggage.