Pimento Cheese Sausage Balls

You’ll be all set for the big game or holiday gathering with these amazing Southern style bite size sausage balls. Made without Bisquick, Pimento Cheese Sausage Balls are a quick and easy appetizer with the added flavor of pimento cheese. Great for breakfast, holidays and of course game day!

Thank you Neese’s Sausage for sponsoring this post.

Anyone that has ever been to our house to watch a sporting event, knows there’s a good chance that one of the appetizers I’ll be serving will be sausage balls made with Neese’s sausage. They are an all time favorite appetizer.

But this year, I decided to change up my classic recipe, made without Bisquick, and create pimento cheese sausage balls.

If you’re not familiar with Neese’s sausage, they’re a family owned business located in my home town here in North Carolina. They’ve been around for over a 100 years and it’s the only sausage I ever use. They use local ingredients and their product is always fresh, never frozen. It can be found in North and South Carolina and Virginia. You can also order it on line for those outside of the area.

What you’ll love about Neese’s Sausage is that it has no preservatives and since it’s never frozen, you can guarantee that it’s always fresh. While fresh is awesome, it’s the flavor that will win you over.

It has just the right mixture of seasoning that you’ll love in a breakfast sausage whether you’re using it for this sausage ball recipe or just serving it along side a stack of waffles.

Traditionally sausage balls are made with Bisquick and cheddar cheese. However, I try to avoid using processed food when possible so this recipe for sausage cheese balls does not contain Bisquick. Everyone agrees that they’re so much better with a lighter almost biscuit like texture.

If you’re from the South or have visited, you’re sure to have eaten pimento cheese, it’s a staple at any party or gathering. Since I love the flavor, it just made sense to combine these two Southern classics.

What you’ll find is a cheesy sausage ball with a pop of flavor from the sharp cheddar cheese and pimentos. The mayonnaise in the pimento cheese actually keeps the sausage balls from drying out.

What is pimento cheese

For those who haven’t experienced the wonder of Pimento cheese, it’s a mayonnaise based spread made from shredded cheddar cheese, mayonnaise and pimentos. It’s a staple in the South with 80% of all pimento cheese consumed in the Southeast with North Carolina as the leading consumer of pimento cheese.

We serve it on biscuits or crackers and as a dip for chips and celery. It’s also great for a grilled cheese or to top a burger. You can change it up and add chipotle peppers for a smokey version, but all versions have cheddar cheese and mayonnaise and of course pimentos.

Why you’ll love pimento cheese sausage balls

• You don’t need a box of Bisquick
• They are quick and easy, you can prepare these in about 15 minutes
• You don’t need any special equipment
• Just 5 ingredients and you probably have all but the sausage and pimento cheese
• Everyone LOVES sausage balls

What you’ll need

• Neese’s sausage – I used their spicy sausage to add some heat. The quality of the sausage you use will affect the taste and flavor of your sausage balls, so if you’re in an area where you can’t find Neese’s, try to find a good quality breakfast sausage.
• Pimento cheese – you can use your favorite brand, try to choose one that does not have a lot of mayonnaise, if it’s runny, you’ll need to add more flour. For this recipe, try to find a thick pimento cheese.
• Pantry staples – flour, baking powder, butter

How to make the best sausage balls

You’re not going to believe how easy sausage balls are to make, all you need is a bowl and a baking sheet. It will be easier if you have a stand mixer or food processor, but I’ve made these a million times with just my hands.

Step 1

Add flour, baking powder and salt to a mixing bowl. Add cold butter and use your fingers to pinch it into the flour. Next add the pimento cheese and mix until it is incorporated.

Step 2

Add the sausage a little at a time and mix until it is combined. (it helps if the sausage has been sitting out for about 15 minutes)

Step 3

Use a cookie scoop to form 1-2 tablespoon sized balls and then roll them between your hands to form smooth balls. Place on a baking sheet and bake until golden brown.

Pimento cheese sausage balls are best served warm, right out of the oven, but since they have a little more moisture from the pimento cheese than regular sausage balls, they won’t dry out as quickly when they come to room temperature.

If you’re looking for more appetizers to serve for the big games coming up, check out these 25 amazing game day appetizers, you’re sure to find something you’ll love. You can update a classic and make French onion dip but add caramelized onions.

Recipe tips

• Let the sausage warm up for about 15 minutes on the counter, this helps the mixture come together easier. This is especially helpful if you’re mixing these with your hands.
• If you don’t have a mixer or food processor, just use your hands to mix everything together.
• These have very little grease so a rack is not needed, just cook them on a sheet of parchment paper.
• Try to get the balls about the same size for even cooking.
• If the sausage mixture is crumbly and won’t form into smooth balls, add a little milk and if it’s so sticky that you can’t work with it, add a little more flour.

Variations

• Traditional sausage balls made without Bisquick and sharp cheddar cheese.
• Make sausage balls with almond flour for a gluten free, low carb version. The texture is slightly different but they are equally delicious.

FAQs and tips

More sausage recipes you’ll love

If you loved this recipe, give it a star ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ rating! Also, snap a picture of your finished dish and share it with me on Instagram using the hashtag #butterandbaggage and tagging me @butterandbaggage.