• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Butter & Baggage logo
  • Home
  • Recipe Search
    • Recipe Index
    • Appetizers
    • Breads & Biscuits
    • Breakfast
      • Muffins
    • Desserts
      • Bars
      • Brownies
      • Cakes & Cupcakes
      • Cookies
      • Fruit Desserts
      • Pies, Cobblers & Crisps
    • Main Dishes
      • Beef
      • Chicken
      • Pork
      • Seafood
    • Pasta
    • Salads
    • Sauces & Dips
    • Side Dishes
    • Snacks
    • Soups & Chilis
  • Portfolio
  • About
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
menu icon
go to homepage
subscribe
search icon
Homepage link
  • Home
  • Recipe Search
  • Recipe Index
  • Portfolio
  • About
  • Contact
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
  • ×

    Home » Recipes » Desserts » Cookies » Best Cookies for a Cookie Exchange

    Best Cookies for a Cookie Exchange

    Published: Nov 12, 2021 · Modified: Nov 12, 2021 by Barbara Curry · This post may contain affiliate links.

    • Share
    • Tweet

    Too busy to host a dinner party, try a cookie exchange instead. You send everyone home with a variety of cookies to enjoy during the holidays and you get to hang out with friends.

    A tiered tray with three different cookies on it.

    There’s nothing like a cookie during the holidays and a cookie exchange is a great way to share your favorite recipe and gather some new ones from your friends. I don’t know about you, but at Christmas I tend to make the family favorites. Hosting a cookie swap allows you to try out some new recipes and maybe add to your favorite list. Need some help deciding on what are the best cookies for a cookie exchange, I’ve got some great ideas.

    Table of contents

    • What is a cookie exchange
    • Why you’ll love it
    • How to host a cookie swap
    • What should you serve at a cookie swap
    • Christmas Sprinkle Cookies
    • Peanut Butter Kiss Cookies
    • Peppermint Fudge
    • Cranberry White Chocolate Shortbread Cookies
    • Chocolate Peppermint Cookies
    • Peanut Butter Snowballs
    • Eggnog Cookies
    • Cornflake Wreaths
    • Peppermint Blondies
    • Lemon Curd Cookies
    • Whole Wheat Spritz Cookies
    • M&M’s Christmas Bark
    • Stained Glass Sugar Cookies
    • No Bake Chocolate Oatmeal Peanut Butter Cookies
    • Pistachio Cranberry Cookies
    • FAQs and tips

    What is a cookie exchange

    A cookie exchange or cookie swap is where you make several dozen of one type of cookie and invite several friends to do the same. Everyone brings their cookies and goes home with a variety to eat during the holidays. You end up with a wide variety of cookies and you only had to make one kind.

    What I enjoy the most about cookie exchanges is having an excuse to get together with friends that doesn’t require a big time commitment. No dinner to fret over, just some snacks and drinks.

    Why you’ll love it

    • You get a wide variety of cookies to enjoy over the holidays.
    • You only have to make one type of cookie which is much quicker and easier than making ten!
    • If you’re hosting a party later, you already have cookies to serve.
    • It’s a great way to get together with friends without having to do much work.

    How to host a cookie swap

    When hosting a cookie swap, have everyone bring enough cookies to share a dozen or half dozen with all the guests. If it’s a small group, 6-8, go with a dozen. If any larger, then go with a half dozen. Making 12 dozen cookies is a lot of work, 6 is manageable.

    When you send out your invitations, ask your friends to tell you what type of cookie they are going to bring. You don’t want duplicates. If they don’t have a favorite cookie, a dessert bar or fudge are nice additions. Have them send you a copy of the recipe so you can print one out for everyone to take home with them.

    If you want to be creative you could pick a theme and have everyone bring a peppermint dessert or cookies that have red or green in them, or frosted cookies.

    Also plan ahead and have plastic bags or treat boxes to package their cookies in. You can find them on Amazon, this box should work for several dozen cookies.

    What should you serve at a cookie swap

    You don’t want to eat up all the beautiful cookies and not have enough to send home with your friends. So instead of eating cookies, try some simple appetizers and serve them with wine or a favorite holiday punch. Here are some favorite appetizers that you can make ahead and which are still scrumptious at room temperature if the party goes long.

    • Mini Croque Monsieur
    • Pinwheel Recipe with Puff Pastry
    • Cream Cheese Crescent Rolls
    • Homemade Chex Mix

    If you want to make something more substantial, you could serve pulled pork or chicken sliders made in the slow cooker, or a big pot of chili and cornbread, all of these can be made in advance and won’t take you away from your guests.

    For inspiration, whether you’re hosting or bringing cookies to a cookie swap, here are some of my favorites along with some from some fabulous bloggers that I know you’ll love. You’ll find some classics along with some twists.

    Christmas Sprinkle Cookies

    Sprinkle cookies with piped trees on top

    Christmas Sprinkle Cookies combine the BEST sprinkle cookie recipe ever with some holiday decorations.  Fun and EASY to decorate but even more fun to eat!

    Read More

    Peanut Butter Kiss Cookies

    A platter of Hershey Kisses cookies.

    Tender, perfect Peanut Butter Kiss Cookies (from Pip and Ebby) are a classic holiday or any-time dessert. Super easy to make, these are the softest, chewiest cookies you’ll make! The Hershey’s Kiss pressed into the center MAKES the cookie!

    Read More

    Peppermint Fudge

    A marble tray filled with peppermint fudge.

    Peppermint Fudge is just what you need during the holiday season.  It’s so quick and easy to make and everyone loves the creamy texture of Christmas fudge. A perfect gift for someone special.

    Read More

    Cranberry White Chocolate Shortbread Cookies

    Cranberry shortbread cookies on a marble background.

    These easy six-ingredient Cranberry White Chocolate Shortbread Cookies (from Cup of Zest) are a fantastic holiday treat perfect for a cookie swap party!

    Read More

    Chocolate Peppermint Cookies

    A glass of milk and chocolate Christmas cookies.

    Rich chocolate cookies filled with white chocolate peppermint bark are a decadent holiday treat. Brownie like cookies with a hint of peppermint that are great for cookie exchanges and holiday parties.

    Read More

    Peanut Butter Snowballs

    Snowball cookies with red and green sprinkles.

    Peanut Butter Snowballs (from Emily Enchanted) are a peanut butter truffle with flavors of honey and vanilla. These no bake peanut butter balls make a delicious Christmas treat that you can pop in your mouth.

    Read More

    Eggnog Cookies

    A rack of frosted cookies sprinkles with cinnamon.

    Frosted Eggnog Cookies are a soft, cake-like, holiday cookie for all eggnog lovers. With a buttery eggnog frosting it’s soon to be your new favorite holiday cookie.

    Read More

    Cornflake Wreaths

    Cornflake wreath cookies on a platter.

    I’m not sure why, but ever since I was a child Cornflake Wreaths (from Savory Experiments) trigger the ultimate of Christmas feelings.

    Read More

    Peppermint Blondies

    Peppermint blondies on parchment paper.

    White chocolate peppermint blondies taste just like Christmas. With a bit of crushed candy canes in the blondie and more in the frosting, it’s the perfect amount of peppermint.

    Read More

    Lemon Curd Cookies

    A serving plate full of lemon curd cookies next to a cup of coffee and a couple of cookies placed on a small plate.

    Technically not a drop cookie, these lemon curd cookies (from Josie + Nina) are a tart bite of buttery flakiness. If you’re a shortbread lover, you’ll be smitten because the dough has only 3 ingredients! Perfect for an afternoon tea—lemon thumbprint cookies are a holiday cookie tray must. 

    Read More

    Whole Wheat Spritz Cookies

    Spritze cookies with blue sprinkles.

    Whole Wheat Spritz cookies (from A Red Spatula) are such a healthier twist on the classic Christmas cookie! They are fairly simple to make and the only special tool needed is the cookie press. Don’t be intimidated by this recipe, it is actually pretty simple! Don’t hold spritz cookies to only being a Christmas cookie, I think they can easily be a cookie enjoyed year-round.

    Read More

    M&M’s Christmas Bark

    Christmas bark piled on a serving board.

    M&M’s Christmas Bark (from Fox Valley Foodie) is quick and easy chocolate holiday treat loaded with white chocolate, pretzels, and plenty of M&M’s!

    Read More

    Stained Glass Sugar Cookies

    Stained glass cookies in the shape of stars.

    A fun and unique Christmas cookie recipe, these Stained Glass Sugar Cookies (from Sugar Spice and Glitter) are super easy to make with the kids. You can make the windows all one color or add a mix of different candies to make marbled stained glass cookies!

    Read More

    No Bake Chocolate Oatmeal Peanut Butter Cookies

    No bake cookies on a platter.

    These No Bake Chocolate Oatmeal Peanut Butter Cookies (from Hot Pan Kitchen) are the best for when you want a gluten free treat but don’t have a lot of time. Made with cocoa powder, maple syrup, and old fashioned oats, they might even be considered healthy. This is a classic cookie recipe that kids absolutely love!

    Read More

    Pistachio Cranberry Cookies

    White serving plate with a bunch of pistachio cranberry cookies on it.

    These Pistachio Cranberry cookies (from Intentional Hospitality) have a soft and chewy dough with a hint of almond and vanilla. Crunchy bits of pistachios and pistachio pudding mix flavor the dough. Butter and dried cranberries add sweetness to each bite of the cookie.

    Read More

    FAQs and tips

    What are the best containers for a cookie swap?

    Resealable plastic bags work the best to keep the flavors of the cookies separated. However, you can find cute holiday themed boxes at Amazon.

    How can you avoid duplicate cookies?

    Check with your friends beforehand to make sure there are no duplicates. Most people have more than one favorite cookie recipe.

    How many people should you invite to a cookie exchange?

    6-8 is a great number because everyone will only need to make 6-8 dozen cookies. If you have more, send your guests home with ½ dozen cookies instead of a dozen of each type.

    « Black Forest Pie
    Thanksgiving Pie Recipes »

    Reader Interactions

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Recipe Rating




    Primary Sidebar

    Barbara Curry is the culinary adventurer of Butter & Baggage. With a dedicated enthusiasm for real butter made from happy cows she is in constant pursuit of delicious recipes and tasty dishes. She shares her experiences, ventures, and occasional misadventures because let’s face it things can get messy in any kitchen.

    More about me →

    Subscribe

    Strawberry Recipes

    • Strawberry Jam Cake
    • Strawberry Jam without Pectin
    • Strawberry Pound Cake
    • Sheet Pan Pancakes
    • Strawberry Cobbler
    • Strawberry Biscuits

    Popular

    • Breakfast Puff Pastry (VIDEO)
    • Steak Marsala
    • Queso Chicken
    • Sausage Balls Recipe
    • Chocolate Bark Recipe
    • Mini Croque Monsieur

    Footer

    Footer

    ↑ back to top

    breakfast bread chicken pasta dessert bars

    COPYRIGHT © 2022 BUTTER & BAGGAGE | PRIVACY POLICY
    BRANDING & CUSTOMIZATION BY GRACE + VINE STUDIOS

    35 shares
    35 shares